What to automate first: a simple sorting method for SMEs

Frequency, time spent, risk of error, ease of setup: four criteria are enough to sort your tasks. The goal is to come out with one line to tackle, and no sprawling project.

By Nuredin Mohamed Ali

What to automate first? The task that comes back often, takes real time, causes trouble when done badly and can be set up without reorganising everything. Just one, picked with a four-criteria grid you can fill in yourself, with no tool and no provider. Everything else waits its turn.

This exercise protects you from a common reflex among business owners new to the subject: wanting to connect everything at once, from first contact to invoice. A project that size tends to drag on, tie up the whole team and deliver late. One well-chosen task shows a visible result sooner and tells you how your team reacts to change.

Before the grid: a list from an ordinary week

You cannot sort from memory. During a week with nothing special going on, ask each person to write down the actions they repeat: what they do, when, and in which tool. One line per task is plenty. "Copy website enquiries into the sheet", "send the payment reminder", "prepare Monday's report".

Two instructions make this list useful. First, describe a precise action: "admin" cannot be sorted, whereas "rename and file supplier invoices" can. Second, ask the people who do the work. An owner sees the outcome of these tasks and rarely the detours they force on whoever handles them.

What to automate first: the four criteria in the grid

Go back through each line and rate it on each criterion: low, medium or high. Stick to these three levels. A finer score would suggest a precision you do not have.

Frequency

How often does the task come back? A daily action, especially one repeated by several people, rates high. An annual file rates low, however tedious. This criterion carries weight for another reason too: every repetition is a chance to compare the result and adjust the setup.

Time spent

Count everything around the action: looking for the information, opening the right file, waiting for a reply, fixing a mistake. A "quick" follow-up becomes a long one when someone first has to find the quote and check it has not already been accepted. If the task interrupts someone several times a day, factor that in too.

Risk of error

What happens when the action is done badly or forgotten? A wrong amount on an invoice, a double booking, an enquiry left unanswered: high. A badly named file you find again the next day: low.

High risk is a reason to tackle the task, on one condition: a person approves the result before it leaves the company. Locabus, a moving van rental business in Moutier, does this with its invoice for extra kilometres, which is reviewed before it goes out.

Ease of setup

Is the information already in a digital tool? Does the rule fit in a few sentences? Are exceptions rare? If so, rate it high. If the task depends on handwritten forms, software that cannot be connected, or a person who "just knows how" without being able to explain it, rate it low. On this criterion, high therefore means easy.

Reading the grid and keeping one line

Once the grid is complete, work in this order.

  1. Cross out lines rated low on both frequency and time spent. They may be irritating, but they do not weigh much.
  2. Cross out lines rated low on ease. They will come back later, once the data is in order.
  3. From what remains, keep the lines with the most "high" ratings.
  4. If there is a tie, take the easiest. A first result that actually runs is worth more than an ambitious project standing still.
  5. Circle one line only. The others go onto a waiting list you will reopen later.

Three temptations often skew this exercise:

  • The most annoying task. Everyone may hate a rare chore. Your irritation deserves a hearing, but it is not in the grid.
  • The most impressive task. An AI assistant on the website looks great in a meeting. If it handles few messages and needs a lot of tuning, it drops out.
  • The task built on a mess. Automating a confusing process only reproduces the confusion faster. Clarify who does what first, then run the line through the grid again.

A garage runs its list through the grid

Picture a garage near Lausanne weighing up three ideas.

An assistant answering questions on the website. Medium frequency, low time spent, high risk because a wrong answer about a price can be costly, and low ease because the questions vary widely. Set aside for now.

Invoicing for repairs. High frequency, high time spent, high risk. Ease stays low, because repair orders are still handwritten. This line will return the day those forms are entered on a screen.

Appointment reminders. High frequency, medium time spent since someone phones customers every day, medium risk since a missed appointment leaves a lift standing empty. High ease: appointments are already in the calendar. This line gets picked.

The choice looks modest. Its advantage is that everyone understands it, and it puts in place what the next step will need: an alert if a message fails to send, and a person who answers when a customer asks to change a date.

Why one task at a time

A single task can be tested on real files with one person responsible. You see what the team accepts, what breaks, and what needed spelling out. Those lessons feed the next line, and they cost far less to learn on a small scope.

Before launch, put three things in writing:

  • who keeps the important decisions and when they step in;
  • who receives the alert when the workflow fails;
  • how the team takes the task back by hand until it is fixed.

Once the task has settled, reopen the grid. It will have shifted: some lines get simpler because the data is now clean. If your winning line concerns payments, automating reminders for quotes and invoices is a good starting point.

You can also bring your grid to us: our page on automation for small businesses describes how we work. Our AI automation offer follows the same logic: a single process, starting at CHF 1'200, in 2 weeks, as listed on our pricing page.

Frequently asked questions

Which task should I start with if everything feels urgent?

Among the lines rated high on frequency, take the one that is easiest to set up. It gives you a concrete result and some first-hand experience before you tackle anything heavier.

Should I start with the department that complains the most?

Listen to it, then run its tasks through the grid like any others. A complaint points to a problem without saying whether automation is the answer. Sometimes clearer instructions are enough.

Can we go straight to AI?

You can, if the task involves reading free text such as emails. For a task with a fixed rule, standard automation is simpler to monitor. Either way, a person approves what matters.

What if no task stands out?

That often means your information is scattered. Start by gathering enquiries or orders in a single sheet: this simple step pushes several lines up the grid.

Start the list this week. The week after, fill in the grid with whoever knows the day-to-day work best, and circle one line. That decision costs nothing, and it gives you a concrete starting point.

Discover our services · Chat on WhatsApp

Read next

Geneva and French-speaking Switzerland

A project? Let's talk for 15 minutes.

Replies within 24 hours.